Â鶹´«Ã½

Sci-Tech

    • Can AI be an author? Federal Court asked to decide in new copyright case

    People check their phones as AMECA, an AI robot, looks on at the All In artificial intelligence conference Thursday, September 28, 2023 in Montreal.THE CANADIAN PRESS/Ryan Remiorz People check their phones as AMECA, an AI robot, looks on at the All In artificial intelligence conference Thursday, September 28, 2023 in Montreal.THE CANADIAN PRESS/Ryan Remiorz
    Share

    The Federal Court of Canada is being asked to declare that only humans — and not artificial intelligence — can be considered authors under Canada’s copyright law.

    It’s the first court case in the country testing how the Copyright Act treats artificially generated content, like the text, images and videos created by systems such as ChatGPT.

    David Fewer, director and general counsel at the University of Ottawa’s Samuelson-Glushko Canadian Internet Policy and Public Interest Clinic, says one of the aims of the clinic’s application is to lay "down in bedrock" that only humans are authors under the law.

    The time to do that is now, given the volume of AI-generated content that’s being produced, Fewer said.

    AI and copyright are at an inflection point, and we’re at the start of a wave of content "being put before our eyes that was generated by an AI and not by a human," he said.

    "It's important at this point, just before this stuff enters the commercial zone in a really serious way, that we get rules down."

    Copyright law grants humans powerful rights, Fewer argued, and it’s important that they don’t get extended to "things that aren't human, on things that don't need that incentive scheme, and don't merit the reward that copyright bestows on authors."

    The case challenges a registration made two years ago by an intellectual property lawyer from India. Ankit Sahni used AI to combine his own photo of a sunset with Vincent van Gogh’s The Starry Night painting, the court application says.

    Sahni then tried to register the resulting image, titled “Suryast,†in copyright registries around the world. In December, the United States Copyright Review Board refused to register it. Its status is unclear in India.

    The application says that in Canada, where the Canadian Intellectual Property Office grants copyright applications instantaneously and without verification, “Suryast†was granted copyright registration in 2021.

    A spokesperson for Innovation Canada, where the intellectual property office is housed, said the system is set up so that the courts determine authorship.

    “A person who believes a work has been registered in contravention with the Copyright Act can make an application to the Federal Court, which can in turn make an order to expunge from the register an entry if it is an appropriate remedy.â€

    The spokesperson said the intellectual property office “takes no position in relation to these matters.â€

    The India-based law firm listed on the court documents under Sahni’s name did not respond to a request for comment by deadline.

    The Canadian Intellectual Property Office registration set a precedent that the office accepts AI authorship and has "led to Canada gaining publicity as one of the only jurisdictions in the world recognizing copyright in works ‘authored’ by an AI," the application argues.

    That’s one of the issues currently under consideration by the federal government, which is in the process of deciding how the Copyright Act should treat artificial intelligence.

    The question of AI authorship was a central one in a recent consultation on AI and copyright, in which the government said it was open to considering different approaches.

    That included both clarifying that copyright protection applies only to human-created works, and an approach that "could mean that AI-generated works receive similar copyright protection as works created by humans."

    In that consultation, Canadian creators and publishers asked Ottawa to do something about the unauthorized and usually unreported use of their content to train generative artificial intelligence systems.

    Unlike in the United States, which has seen numerous lawsuits launched, copyright holders in Canada have so far shied away from challenging that use in the courts.

    Fewer called that surprising.

    "It may be that the big stakeholders in Canada are waiting to see if Parliament is going to do anything with the consultations that it's recently held,†or that they may have decided pursuing licensing schemes is a better approach, he suggested.

    This report by The Canadian Press was first published July 13, 2024. 

    CTVNews.ca Top Stories

    The wildfire fight in central B.C. intensified Friday, according to officials.

    A university student from Brampton was killed when two shooters fired indiscriminately into a crowded plaza in Toronto last month in what police say was a 'cowardly act.'

    What some B.C. construction workers describe as the worst aspect of their jobs will be coming to an end next month, the province announced.

    Three teens were arrested for an armed robbery at a Kitchener jewelry store after witnesses caught and detained the suspects until officers arrived on scene.

    Mary Grace Rico is seeking help in getting treatment for a rare spinal condition.

    Canada

    • Guelph tenants worry they'll have find a new home after recently receiving N-13 notices from their new apartment owner.

    • Three teens were arrested for an armed robbery at a Kitchener jewelry store after witnesses caught and detained the suspects until officers arrived on scene.

    • Grand Chief Cathy Merrick of the Assembly of Manitoba Chiefs will lie in state at the provincial legislature following her sudden death.

    • Mary Grace Rico is seeking help in getting treatment for a rare spinal condition.

    • Nearly seven weeks since a wildfire forced the evacuation of Jasper National Park and burned nearly a third of the townsite's structures, Parks Canada says the blaze is now officially under control.

    • What some B.C. construction workers describe as the worst aspect of their jobs will be coming to an end next month, the province announced.

    World

    Politics

    Health

    • It’s been just over a week since the federal government banned nicotine pouches from being sold anywhere other than a pharmacy.

    • Mary Grace Rico is seeking help in getting treatment for a rare spinal condition.

    Sci-Tech

    Entertainment

    Business

    Lifestyle

    Sports

    • The Worm made a guest appearance on WWE's Smackdown at Rogers Place Friday night.

    • An emotional memorial was held Friday for Johnny and Matthew Gaudreau at their old high school in Gloucester City, New Jersey.

    Autos

    • Nearly two-dozen drivers were caught in a speed trap outside a Vancouver elementary school on Thursday – as students were settling back into their daily routines.

    • An Ontario man said he couldn't believe an electric car he bought three years ago for $20,000 would need a new battery at a cost of more than $33,000.

    Local Spotlight

    Roger Barker was looking forward to exchanging a book at one of the Little Free Libraries that had been erected in his neighbourhood, until he found it vandalized.

    You never know what you might find in your doorbell camera footage...

    Brenda Tremblay has been an avid gardener for the last 40 years, but this year’s harvest in Colpitts Settlement, N.B., is a tough nut to crack.

    A group of seniors in Ontario is offering their time and experience as parents struggle to find reliable child care spaces.

    Saskatchewan man Clyde Hall has been collecting and restoring antique farm equipment for five decades. He's now ready to part with his collection.

    An Ottawa man has won the $3.8 million prize in the 'Catch the Ace' draw in Maniwaki, Que. Local radio station CHGA 97.3 has been playing their version of 'Catch the Ace' for nearly a year without a winner.

    Herds of salamanders are crossing the road in western Manitoba by the dozens.

    A black bear cub survived a 10-hour drive to Windsor while being fed Taco Bell after being found in the middle of a road near Cochrane, Ont.

    A British Columbia woman who unsuccessfully sued her downstairs neighbour last fall for making too much noise has now failed in a bid to sue her upstairs neighbour for being too loud.

    • One of the vessels that services the busy Tsawwassen-Swartz Bay route will be out of commission for about six months after its propeller fell off, according to BC Ferries.

    • Tennis players were in for a nasty surprise at a Victoria park on Friday, when feces were discovered smeared around the courts.

    • Mounties in northwestern B.C. say they have arrested the suspect in a fatal shooting almost exactly a year after it occurred.

    • A university student from Brampton was killed when two shooters fired indiscriminately into a crowded plaza in Toronto last month in what police say was a 'cowardly act.'

    • A Peterborough police officer has been charged with breach of trust and possession of property obtained by crime.

    • A woman is in hospital in life-threatening condition after she was struck in a hit-and-run in Whitby early Saturday morning.

    • Calgary water consumption ticked up to 505 million litres Friday as sweltering mid-summer temperatures drove up demand.

    • An emotional memorial was held Friday for Johnny and Matthew Gaudreau at their old high school in Gloucester City, New Jersey.

    • The Bank of Canada has lowered its key interest rate by 25 basis points to 4.25 per cent.

    • Ottawa Fire Services says two adults have been displaced following a fire that started in the garage of their home in Orleans Friday evening.

    • Canadian para canoeist Brianna Hennessy raced to her first Paralympic medal with a reminder of her mother on her paddle.

    • Brandon Reid was a promising NHLer for the Vancouver Canucks, but his struggles with addiction almost killed him. He now trains other addicts as they fight to stay sober.

    • Family and community members gathered in Montreal's Cartierville neighbourhood on Saturday to pay respects to a 14-year-old boy who was killed while riding a scooter in the summer.

    • A petition has garnered more than 10,000 signatures calling for the Quebec subsidy for service dogs to be extended to those with autism.

    • Nearly seven weeks since a wildfire forced the evacuation of Jasper National Park and burned nearly a third of the townsite's structures, Parks Canada says the blaze is now officially under control.

    • A woman is dead and a man is in hospital after an SUV and a pick-up truck crashed on Highway 13 near Sedgewick on Friday.

    • The family of a man shot and killed by police have launched a $1 million lawsuit against the Edmonton Police Service, the police chief and four officers.

    • The Nova Scotia RCMP has issued a formal apology to African Nova Scotians and people of African descent for the historic use of street checks and other harmful interactions.

    • The Nova Scotia Health Authority has released more information about the significant flooding at the Cape Breton Regional Hospital on August 25.

    • Grand Chief Cathy Merrick of the Assembly of Manitoba Chiefs will lie in state at the provincial legislature following her sudden death.

    • The Winnipeg Blue Bombers defeated the Saskatchewan Roughriders 26-21 on Saturday, marking the team's fifth-straight victory and fifth Banjo Bowl win in a row.

    • Corn maze season has officially begun throughout Manitoba – a sign that fall is just around the corner.

    • The North Central Community Association has partnered with the Rainbow Youth Centre on a new mural in the heart of North Central.

    • A local elder was honoured at Westminster United Church on Saturday by having a medicine wheel dedicated to her.

    • The victory moved the Bombers into top spot in the CFL's West Division, while the Roughriders remain in third after failing to win for a seventh straight outing.

    • Three teens were arrested for an armed robbery at a Kitchener jewelry store after witnesses caught and detained the suspects until officers arrived on scene.

    • Guelph tenants worry they'll have find a new home after recently receiving N-13 notices from their new apartment owner.

    • Child care centres that decided not to participate in the national $10-a-day program will soon lose some of their provincial funding.

    • In the wake of the tragic incident of setting a student on fire at Evan Hardy Collegiate, Saskatoon Public Schools announced that it is providing counselling services to students and staff affected by the event.

    • The victory moved the Bombers into top spot in the CFL's West Division, while the Roughriders remain in third after failing to win for a seventh straight outing.

    • Broadway avenue was alive with the bustle of Saskatoon residents enjoying their weekend. The street was closed off and turned into a pedestrian walkway for a massive street festival that saw thousands of participants.

    • A veteran staff sergeant with the Ontario Provincial Police in Sudbury has been sentenced for stealing two items from a First Nations man and hiding what he did while his fellow officers searched for them.

    • Hamilton Police are warning locals of the discovery of fentanyl-laced gummies 'disguised as candy,' after finding them during a recent warrant.

    • The City of London’s municipal enforcement team spent Saturday at 700 units on Kipps Lane, helping tenants address property standards issues.

    • The Strathroy-Caradoc police are investigating a robbery and stabbing following an incident early Saturday morning.

    • The trial of former Woodstock mayor, Trevor Birtch, continued on Friday.

    • Three vehicles were involved in a crash on Bayshore Drive near Frank Street in Midland on Saturday.

    • Officers from Southern Georgian OPP are investigating an alleged overnight sexual assault incident in Midland last weekend.

    • The 35th annual Parkinson Canada 'SuperWalk' in Barrie on Saturday raised more than $30,000 to support Parkinson's Disease research.

    • The Special Investigations Unit’s (SIU) forensic investigators remain on scene Saturday afternoon following Friday’s fatal shooting involving a Windsor police officer.

    • VIDEO

      VIDEO

      Citing a vibrant business and dining scene, more active streets and a perception of greater safety, residents at a new event in Walkerville say the neighborhood has become Windsor's "new downtown," outshining the traditional core as the city's most desirable place to be — day or night.

    • Chatham-Kent police are reminding drivers to watch for deer while out on the roads, especially at dusk and dawn.

    • Tennis players were in for a nasty surprise at a Victoria park on Friday, when feces were discovered smeared around the courts.

    • One of the vessels that services the busy Tsawwassen-Swartz Bay route will be out of commission for about six months after its propeller fell off, according to BC Ferries.

    • Police in Victoria say they arrested a man they found in possession of a loaded handgun and more than $29,000 worth of cash earlier this week.

    • Mounties in northwestern B.C. say they have arrested the suspect in a fatal shooting almost exactly a year after it occurred.

    • A man has now been charged for his alleged role in a hit-and-run that killed a teenager in Kelowna, B.C., last fall.

    • Mounties in Kelowna are appealing to the public for help reuniting a stolen puppy named Lulu with its owner.

    • It’s been just over a week since the federal government banned nicotine pouches from being sold anywhere other than a pharmacy.

    • A more inclusive and welcoming land acknowledgment has been released by the City of Lethbridge.

    • Those looking to do some de-cluttering ahead of the fall can put their unwanted items on their front lawn for the annual Reuse Rendezvous this weekend.

    • The Robinson Huron Treaty of 1850 Gathering 2024 will take place in Greater Sudbury at the Anderson Farm Museum on Sept. 8 and 9.

    • A pasta shortage in Sault Ste. Marie is almost never the case, but for one local food bank, the common carb was a rare sight just a few weeks ago.

    • A 41-year-old resident of the Sault is accused of posing as a teacher from Wasaga Beach and threatening a child from a nearby community into sending intimate images of themselves.

    N.L.

    Shopping Trends

    The Shopping Trends team is independent of the journalists at Â鶹´«Ã½. We may earn a commission when you use our links to shop. Read about us.

    Stay Connected
    Follow Â鶹´«Ã½