Â鶹´«Ă˝

Politics

    • Panel considered public warning about interference in 2021 election, inquiry hears

    Share
    OTTAWA -

    A panel of top bureaucrats considered warning the public about possible foreign interference in the last general election, but ultimately decided against it, a senior official testified at a federal inquiry Friday.

    That decision was made, in part, because a potential misinformation campaign was likely only to reach the Chinese diaspora, said Allen Sutherland, who works in the Privy Council Office as an assistant secretary to the cabinet.

    Sutherland prepared the agenda and sat in on the meetings of the so-called panel of five, which was responsible for issuing a public warning if they believed an incident -- or an accumulation of incidents -- threatened Canada's ability to have a free and fair election.

    There was no such announcement in 2021 or concerning the 2019 election.

    Even so, allegations of foreign interference in those ballots — suggestions fuelled by anonymous leaks to the media — led to a chorus of calls for the public inquiry now underway.

    The commission is expected to release its interim findings by May 3, and a full report by the end of the year.

    The panel of five was comprised of the clerk of the Privy Council, the national security adviser, the deputy attorney general and the deputy ministers of public safety and foreign affairs.

    Panel members learned of concerns about information circulating on the social-media app WeChat in Mandarin during the 2021 campaign. 

    The Conservative party flagged a possible misinformation campaign regarding the party's platform and attitudes toward China. Former Conservative leader Erin O'Toole told the inquiry earlier this week he believes it may have cost the party as many as nine seats.

    The bureaucrats discussed whether a public warning was warranted, Sutherland said, and he compared it to an earlier situation involving a false news article that spread inflammatory misinformation about Prime Minister Justin Trudeau in 2019.

    The fact the WeChat messages were in Mandarin meant the information would likely only reach the Chinese diaspora, in contrast to the fake news article that was in English and had the potential to "go viral" nationally.

    "I do not want to leave you with the impression that it was treated with any less seriousness," Sutherland told the commission.

    It was just one of the factors that led the panel to opt against a public warning in what was ultimately a nuanced judgment call, he said.

    The lack of evidence to link the campaign definitively to China and the fact that the posts referred to "substantive policy issues" as opposed to outright false allegations also weighed against the decision to issue a warning, Sutherland said in a summary of an interview he gave to the commission before his testimony.

    On Friday, he told the inquiry there were discussions about the threshold for making a public announcement, and he indicated it would happen, for instance, if the spread of false information was persistent and could affect people's voting decisions.

    "It was understood that it would only be done as kind of a last resort when the democratic ecosystem didn't cleanse itself -- that there wasn't someone debunking the information."

    As part of his work, Sutherland had developed relationships with the Canadian directors of social-media companies such as Facebook, Twitter and Microsoft.

    Following the terms of a voluntary arrangement, these companies would sometimes identify inauthentic activity on their platforms and bring it to his attention.

    Facebook flagged the inflammatory article about Trudeau to Sutherland. At the direction of then-clerk of the Privy Council Ian Shugart, Sutherland then asked Facebook to remove the article and the company complied.

    In his interview with the commission, Sutherland remembered the panel discussing the article to determine whether it reached the threshold for a public announcement. "Because the system had debunked the false news, the panel did not have to make an announcement," the interview summary says.

    According to Sutherland, the panel worried that intervening publicly too frequently would unnecessarily create an impression that Canada's democratic institutions lacked integrity.

    However, the panel members continually discussed the question of what would meet the threshold, and there was a sense it could be met even "if only one or two ridings were affected" by foreign interference, he said.

    The panel received information from sources including the Security and Intelligence Threats to Elections Task Force, composed of representatives of the Canadian Security Intelligence Service, the RCMP, Global Affairs Canada and the Communications Security Establishment, Canada's cyberspy agency. 

    However, the panel members continually discussed the question of what would meet the threshold, and there was a sense it could be met even "if only one or two ridings were affected" by foreign interference, he said.

    The panel received information from sources including the Security and Intelligence Threats to Elections Task Force, composed of representatives of the Canadian Security Intelligence Service, the RCMP, Global Affairs Canada and the Communications Security Establishment, Canada's cyberspy agency.

    The online posts about the Conservative platform, including some on WeChat, were an anomaly, the Global Affairs representative on the task force testified Friday.

    "Our assessment, unfortunately, came up inconclusive," Gallit Dobner told the commission.

    While the misinformation could have been part of a Chinese-government sponsored campaign, there was "zero evidence" to suggest that it was directed by Beijing, she said. The other possibility was that the posts were "purely organic."

    In both the 2019 and 2021 general elections, the Liberals were returned to government with minority mandates while the Conservatives formed the official Opposition.

    Individual political candidates have told the inquiry they were angry to learn only after both election campaigns that officials had been monitoring activity suspected of being linked to foreign states.

    Lyall King, who chaired the SITE task force in the last two elections, said briefings for political party representatives in 2019 were intended to build awareness about foreign interference and help them identify it.

    "We weren't providing them with a level of information that was so specific as to take an immediate action," King said.

    In the lead-up to the 2019 election, China was seen as the most significant threat from an interference perspective.

    The CSIS representative on the task force described China as "at the ceiling" in terms of intent and capability, while other countries were somewhere "around our ankles," says a document tabled at the inquiry.

    Government of Pakistan officials in Canada tried to clandestinely influence Canadian federal politics with the aim of furthering Islamabad's interests, says an intelligence summary presented to the commission.

    As a result, Canadian officials carried out an unspecified measure that effectively reduced the foreign interference threat in advance of the 2019 election, the summary says.

    Another intelligence summary says foreign interference attempts by India are aimed at Canadian politicians and democratic processes at all levels of government.

    Indian officials in Canada have increasingly relied on proxies and the contacts in their networks to conduct such activities, obscuring any explicit link to the Indian government, the document adds.

    India's interference activities during the 2021 election "were centred on a small number of electoral districts," the summary says.

    It adds that some were of interest to India owing to the government's perception that a portion of Indo-Canadian voters were sympathetic to the Khalistani independence movement or pro-Pakistan political stances. 

    This report by The Canadian Press was first published April 5, 2024.

    IN DEPTH

    Opinion

    opinion

    opinion Don Martin: Gusher of Liberal spending won't put out the fire in this dumpster

    A Hail Mary rehash of the greatest hits from the Trudeau government’s three-week travelling pony-show, the 2024 federal budget takes aim at reversing the party’s popularity plunge in the under-40 set, writes political columnist Don Martin. But will it work before the next election?

    opinion

    opinion Don Martin: How a beer break may have doomed the carbon tax hike

    When the Liberal government chopped a planned beer excise tax hike to two per cent from 4.5 per cent and froze future increases until after the next election, says political columnist Don Martin, it almost guaranteed a similar carbon tax move in the offing.

    CTVNews.ca Top Stories

    A team of tornado experts are investigating a path of damage through Wellington County.

    Timmins-James Bay MP Charlie Angus was among approximately 120 people who gathered Sunday night for a candlelight vigil near the scene of a vicious attack against a 16-year-old in Cobalt.

    A B.C. teen has a suspected case of H5N1 avian flu — the first known human to acquire the virus in Canada.

    Canada

    • A 15-year-old boy from Kitchener, Ont. is facing a long list of criminal charges as the Waterloo Regional Police Service wraps up a lengthy swatting investigation.

    • Two nephews of the beloved Harry R. Hamilton share stories about his life and legacy.

    • Timmins-James Bay MP Charlie Angus was among approximately 120 people who gathered Sunday night for a candlelight vigil near the scene of a vicious attack against a 16-year-old in Cobalt.

    • A team of tornado experts are investigating a path of damage through Wellington County.

    • The federal government is urging both sides in the British Columbia port dispute to return to the table after mediated talks broke off on Saturday, the first of three scheduled days.

    World

    Politics

    Health

    Sci-Tech

    Entertainment

    Business

    Lifestyle

    Sports

    • Canada will be without captain Alphonso Davies for its upcoming CONCACAF Nations League quarterfinal against Suriname.

    • The Edmonton Oilers may have found the break they were looking for.

    Autos

    Local Spotlight

    For the second year in a row, the â€Gift-a-Family’ campaign is hoping to make the holidays happier for children and families in need throughout Barrie.

    Some of the most prolific photographers behind CTV Skywatch Pics of the Day use the medium for fun, therapy, and connection.

    A young family from Codroy Valley, N.L., is happy to be on land and resting with their newborn daughter, Miley, after an overwhelming, yet exciting experience at sea.

    As Connor Nijsse prepared to remove some old drywall during his garage renovation, he feared the worst.

    A group of women in Chester, N.S., has been busy on the weekends making quilts – not for themselves, but for those in need.

    A Vancouver artist whose streetside singing led to a chance encounter with one of the world's biggest musicians is encouraging aspiring performers to try their hand at busking.

    Ten-thousand hand-knit poppies were taken from the Sanctuary Arts Centre and displayed on the fence surrounding the Dartmouth Cenotaph on Monday.

    A Vancouver man is saying goodbye to his nine-to-five and embarking on a road trip from the Canadian Arctic to Antarctica.

    • A B.C. woman who stole more than $14,000 in volunteer-raised funds that were supposed to be spent on school supplies and programs – including hot meals for vulnerable kids – won't spend any time in jail.

    • A B.C. teen has a suspected case of H5N1 avian flu — the first known human to acquire the virus in Canada.

    • Discounts abound at a new eatery in downtown Vancouver that offers pizzas and fry towers at a base price of $9.11, as a tribute to first responders.

    • Several hundred people gathered outside the Ontario legislature in Toronto to honour veterans and remember those who died fighting for their country.

    • Toronto is expected to see an economic boost to the tune of nearly $300 million thanks to Taylor Swift’s upcoming Eras Tour, which will be making a stop in Canada’s largest city for a six-show run later this month.

    • A man believed to be in his 40s has been rushed to a trauma centre following a stabbing in downtown Toronto.

    • EXTENDED VIDEO

      EXTENDED VIDEO

      Calgarians observed Remembrance Day at a number of different ceremonies across the city on Monday, including at the Hangar Flight Museum.

    • A memorial walk was held Sunday afternoon by the Calgary branch of the Ukrainian Canadian Congress to “honour the Canadian soldiers who died fighting for peace in the past and the Ukrainian soldiers who are giving their lives for freedom today,” according to a media release.

    • July 2025 may seem like it’s in the distant future, but for the St. Luke playground committee time is ticking to fundraise the $340,000 they still need to build a new playground.

    • Crowds gathered in Ottawa and eastern Ontario on Monday to honour the sacrifice of men and women in uniform who gave their lives in service of Canada.

    • The company confirms it will open the new Chipotle at 5671 Hazeldean Road on Thursday, in the former location of Benny & Co.

    • The Fleet Street Pumping station is Ottawa's oldest water facility. Up to two-thirds of the city's water supply can move through it,

    • A 36-year-old Montreal man who was out on bail after allegedly uttering death threats to a woman is now accused of murdering her on the South Shore.

    • Hundreds of people gathered in downtown Montreal on Monday to mark Remembrance Day and honour Canadians who sacrificed their lives in the great wars and beyond.

    • Private Martine Roy was only 20 years old in 1984 when she was arrested, interrogated and dismissed from the Canadian Armed Forces for being what was then termed a "sexual deviant."

    • Edmonton's Beverly Memorial Cenotaph on Monday hosted its 104th Remembrance Day service to honour past and present veterans.

    • A member of Canadian Forces Base (CFB) Edmonton participated in the national Remembrance Day Ceremony in Ottawa on Monday.

    • Thousands of Maritimers turned out in wet weather Monday to remember those who have served, and continue to serve, in Canada's armed forces for Remembrance Day.

    • A Cape Breton senior recalls her life in German-occupied France, and her mother’s death, during the Second World War.

    • Thousand of people gathered at the Menin Gate in the Ypres, Belgium for Monday’s Remembrance Day Ceremony.

    • Thousands gathered at the RBC Convention Centre on Monday to bear witness to a sombre and historic Remembrance Day ceremony.

    • Four teenagers have been arrested in connection with the attack and robbery of a 62-year-old woman.

    • A sacred fire burning in Winnipeg has brought healing and hope to some members of Xavia Skye Lynn Butler’s family.

    • November 11th marks a solemn day across Canada, and Regina is no exception.

    • Fire crews reported that no one was hurt after flames broke out in a home on Robinson Street in central Regina.

    • Regina author Valerie Crowther is celebrating the release of her book â€War Letters: Linking Lives in the Second World War.’

    • A team of tornado experts are investigating a path of damage through Wellington County.

    • A 15-year-old boy from Kitchener, Ont. is facing a long list of criminal charges as the Waterloo Regional Police Service wraps up a lengthy swatting investigation.

    • Two buildings in downtown Hamilton collapsed early Monday morning but firefighters say no injuries were reported.

    • Saskatchewan RCMP are searching for a suspect after a man was seriously injured in a farm-related incident in Montreal Lake.

    • It was a somber day at Mosaic Stadium as members of the Saskatchewan Roughriders officially cleaned out their stalls and closed the book on the 2024 season.

    • The Regina Rams claimed the Hardy Cup after a hard fought battle against the Saskatoon Huskies 19-14 on Saturday in the first all Saskatchewan U-Sports western conference final since 2002.

    • Timmins-James Bay MP Charlie Angus was among approximately 120 people who gathered Sunday night for a candlelight vigil near the scene of a vicious attack against a 16-year-old in Cobalt.

    • Oxford OPP say that they are investigating a collision that resulted in serious injuries on Sunday evening.

    • A team of tornado experts are investigating a path of damage through Wellington County.

    • WATCH

      WATCH

      The events will start at 10:15 a.m. with a parade that forms up in front of the Delta London Armories, marches east on Dundas Street and turns north onto Waterloo Street to Dufferin Avenue, the west to the Cenotaph.

    • A Barrie man is accused of being at the centre of an alleged $2.2 million stolen used car scheme.

    • An unseasonably mild fall in Simcoe County has put any hopes for an early start to the ski season on hold, still, one local resort has its sights set on the slopes.

    • Environment Canada issued a weather alert for Barrie, Collingwood and surrounding areas, alerting residents about the wicked winds that are expected to pick up to 80 kilometres per hour in the afternoon hours.

    • A local high school honoured veterans of the “Forgotten War” on Monday.

    • After a Canada Border Services Agency (CBSA) worker took their own life while on shift at the Ambassador Bridge Saturday, Â鶹´«Ă˝ Public Safety Analyst Chris Lewis highlighted the mental health burdens faced daily by law enforcement.

    • Representatives of the Windsor Veterans Memorial Services Committee, military representatives, wreath bearers, government officials, and members of the public will attend the Cenotaph at City Hall Square for the outdoor service.

    • A B.C. woman who stole more than $14,000 in volunteer-raised funds that were supposed to be spent on school supplies and programs – including hot meals for vulnerable kids – won't spend any time in jail.

    • A B.C. teen has a suspected case of H5N1 avian flu — the first known human to acquire the virus in Canada.

    • Environment Canada says heavy rain and winds could cause power outages on Vancouver Island as an "intense" storm system is set to hit the B.C. coast Sunday.

    • A B.C. woman who stole more than $14,000 in volunteer-raised funds that were supposed to be spent on school supplies and programs – including hot meals for vulnerable kids – won't spend any time in jail.

    • The emergency department at South Okanagan General Hospital in Oliver, B.C., will be closed for 31 hours this weekend, the second such closure in a week and the third since the start of November.

    • Police in Kamloops, B.C., are reminding parents and guardians to check their children's Halloween candy after receiving a report of a mother finding a razor blade in one of her daughter's treats.

    • The Southern Alberta Recreation Association is officially announcing the Town of Taber as next year’s host for the Southern Alberta Summer Games.

    • The Lethbridge Hurricanes broke open a close game with three goals in the first two minutes of the third period as they defeated the Warriors 7-3 in a game played Friday night in Moose Jaw.

    • There might not a lot snow just yet, but many southern Albertans are still itching to get outdoors.

    • Timmins-James Bay MP Charlie Angus was among approximately 120 people who gathered Sunday night for a candlelight vigil near the scene of a vicious attack against a 16-year-old in Cobalt.

    • It was just days before the COVID-19 pandemic shut the world down when the Shaft Bottom Boys of Sudbury broke a world record for 'Deepest Concert Underground.' Now, more than four years later, a Timmins band is looking to take the title.

    • Police say that a 16-year-old was attacked with a sword Nov. 3 in Cobalt, Ont., in a case of intimate partner violence.

    N.L.

    Stay Connected
    Follow Â鶹´«Ă˝