Â鶹´«Ã½

Politics

    • Jury selection change preserved fairness of process, Supreme Court says

    The Supreme Court of Canada in Ottawa on Friday, Nov. 2, 2018.Sean Kilpatrick/The Canadian Press The Supreme Court of Canada in Ottawa on Friday, Nov. 2, 2018.Sean Kilpatrick/The Canadian Press
    Share
    OTTAWA -

    The Supreme Court of Canada says Parliament was entitled to abolish a long-standing jury selection procedure that some critics had denounced as discriminatory.

    The newly released reasons shed light on the high court's decision from the bench last October upholding the constitutionality of legislation scrapping so-called peremptory challenges.

    Peremptory challenges allowed lawyers for either side to dismiss a certain number of prospective jurors without an explanation.

    They were abolished as part of changes to the jury selection process ushered in by the federal Liberal government to make juries more representative following the controversial acquittal of Gerald Stanley in 2018.

    Stanley was charged with second-degree murder in the killing of Colten Boushie, a 22-year-old Indigenous man, and there were no Indigenous jurors on the panel that heard his case.

    The new rules were contested by Pardeep Singh Chouhan, who faced a first-degree murder charge. His lawyers argued that eliminating peremptory challenges would result in less representative juries, infringing their client's right to be tried by an independent and impartial panel.

    Though a majority of the Supreme Court affirmed the constitutionality of the legislative change, the justices provided several sets of reasons.

    In writing for three members in the majority, justices Michael Moldaver and Russell Brown said the selection regime continues to provide the independent and impartial jury that each accused is owed under the Charter of Rights and Freedoms.

    Moldaver and Brown said peremptory challenges heightened the perception of the accused that he or she had the benefit of a fairly selected tribunal.

    “Accused persons routinely used peremptory challenges based on the way prospective jurors looked at them during the selection process, and there was some evidence that racialized accused used them to make room for jurors with diverse backgrounds.â€

    However, the true value of the procedure was doubtful, Moldaver and Brown wrote.

    “It is not possible to trace the impact of peremptory challenges on the verdict. More critically, peremptory challenges sat uneasily with other aspects of jury selection. They undermined the randomness of jury selection, a significant guarantor of jury independence and impartiality,†Moldaver and Brown wrote.

    “They also had a darker side which allowed for practices born of prejudice and stereotypes, which had palpable and well-documented effects on the composition of juries. Indigenous communities, in particular, have witnessed their disturbing effects.â€

    Further, the charter right to be heard by an impartial tribunal does not entitle the accused to any particular procedure, they said. “The constitutionality of the jury selection process must be considered as a whole.â€

    The abolition of peremptory challenges comes at a time of heightened public awareness of the role of racial prejudice in the criminal justice system, the justices noted.

    But they cautioned: “Fair trial rights do not depend on the subjective perceptions of the accused, and absolute diversity on a jury is unattainable, as no group of 12 could ever represent the innumerable characteristics existing within our diverse and multicultural society.â€

    Other opportunities remain for the parties in criminal trials to raise and address concerns about juror partiality and bias, Moldaver and Brown added.

    The British Columbia Civil Liberties Association intervened in the high court case, contending that peremptory challenges protect jury diversity.

    “We argued that jury diversity is critical because it limits racial bias and promotes jury impartiality,†the association said Friday.

    “But Canadian juries are not diverse. White, wealthy property owners are consistently overrepresented on our juries. Abolishing peremptory challenges will make our juries even less diverse and will violate the charter right to be tried by an impartial tribunal.â€

    This report by The Canadian Press was first published June 25, 2021.

    IN DEPTH

    Opinion

    opinion

    opinion Don Martin: Gusher of Liberal spending won't put out the fire in this dumpster

    A Hail Mary rehash of the greatest hits from the Trudeau government’s three-week travelling pony-show, the 2024 federal budget takes aim at reversing the party’s popularity plunge in the under-40 set, writes political columnist Don Martin. But will it work before the next election?

    opinion

    opinion Don Martin: How a beer break may have doomed the carbon tax hike

    When the Liberal government chopped a planned beer excise tax hike to two per cent from 4.5 per cent and froze future increases until after the next election, says political columnist Don Martin, it almost guaranteed a similar carbon tax move in the offing.

    CTVNews.ca Top Stories

    'Escalating incidents' between two Hamilton high schools are believed to be connected to a car crash last week that left a 15-year-old boy dead, police say.

    The Alberta government is proposing additional restrictions on wind and solar farms that conservationists think are more about limiting renewable energy than protecting the environment.

    Four guests at an Airbnb east of Toronto made off with a quarter of million dollars worth of jewelry following their stay, police say.

    Canada

    • The Alberta government is proposing additional restrictions on wind and solar farms that conservationists think are more about limiting renewable energy than protecting the environment.

    • 'Escalating incidents' between two Hamilton high schools are believed to be connected to a car crash last week that left a 15-year-old boy dead, police say.

    • British Columbia's New Democratic Party says it is responsible for a parody social media post that has B.C. Conservative Leader John Rustad promising to bring back McDonald's McRib sandwiches.

    • Four guests at an Airbnb east of Toronto made off with a quarter of million dollars worth of jewelry following their stay, police say.

    • Students are returning to a Jewish girls' school in Toronto two days after it was struck with gunfire for the second time this year.

    • An especially warm fall in Ontario means the province may not get the colourful array of fall foliage that usually transforms treetops this time of year.

    World

    Politics

    Health

    Sci-Tech

    Entertainment

    Business

    Lifestyle

    Sports

    Autos

    • Elon Musk unveils his 'Cybercab' robotaxi

      Tesla CEO Elon Musk unveiled on Thursday his vision of a 'a fun, exciting future,' an 'age of abundance' full of his company’s self-driving cars without steering wheels, parking lots turned into parks and robots that will walk among the population – that he once again promised would be available within a few years.

    • video

      video

      Dozens of cars were pulled out of the Detroit River in west Windsor on Tuesday, causing many questions for Windsorites.

    Local Spotlight

    Sometimes love is written in the stars, but for one couple, it’s written in the aurora borealis.

    Canadian hip hop artist Dillan King says running 100 marathons in 100 days was not only the hardest thing he has ever done, but the 'proudest accomplishment' of his entire life.

    James Taylor never expected to be walking home with a bag full of groceries he didn't buy.

    This weekend marks the fifth anniversary of a large blizzard that paralyzed Manitoba.

    There was an eye-catching mix of rainbows and lightning over Vancouver following a brief downpour this week.

    Jeff Warner from Aidie Creek Gardens in the northern Ontario community of Englehart has a passion for growing big pumpkins and his effort is paying off in more ways than one.

    Saskatchewan’s Jessica Campbell has made hockey history, becoming the first ever female assistant coach in the National Hockey League (NHL).

    Have you ever seen videos of hovercrafts online or on TV and thought, 'Wow, I wish I could ride one of those.' One Alberta man did, and then built his own.

    A B.C. couple is getting desperate – and creative – in their search for their missing dog.

    • One person has died following a crash between a car and a truck east of Harrison Hot Springs.

    • Sḵwx̱wú7mesh Úxwumixw (Squamish Nation) Chef Paul Natrall, the man behind Indigenous food truck Mr. Bannock, is bringing cooking classes on First Nations fare to schools and offices throughout Metro Vancouver.

    • Surrey RCMP are asking the public to be on the lookout for a man who was first reported missing nearly two weeks ago.

    • 'Escalating incidents' between two Hamilton high schools are believed to be connected to a car crash last week that left a 15-year-old boy dead, police say.

    • Durham police say two men are facing drug and weapon charges after somebody called police about a late-night altercation in Oshawa.

    • Four guests at an Airbnb east of Toronto made off with a quarter of million dollars worth of jewelry following their stay, police say.

    • Calgary libraries will reopen on Wednesday following a cyber security breach.

    • Hundreds of Calgarians gathered together on Thanksgiving Monday to fight food insecurity with a charity walk for The Calgary Food Bank.

    • The Alberta government is proposing additional restrictions on wind and solar farms that conservationists think are more about limiting renewable energy than protecting the environment.

    • On Monday, the Mission capped off its annual Thanksgiving tradition with a meal for anyone who needed one.

    • The Ottawa Police Service is investigating a possible assault that left one man with serious burns on Monday morning.

    • On Monday morning, officers stopped a vehicle that was travelling the wrong way on Baseline Road in Ottawa.

    • Urgences-santé has confirmed that an ambulance was dispatched to a residence in Côte-Saint-Luc following reports of a possible drowning involving a man in his 60s.

    • A Montreal suburb has received a provincial Environment Department permit to go ahead with a long-awaited white-tailed deer cull in a local park that has become overrun with them.

    • Firefighters with the Montreal Fire Service extinguished a two-alarm fire at a vacant building in the Ahuntsic-Cartierville borough on Sunday night.

    • The Alberta government is proposing additional restrictions on wind and solar farms that conservationists think are more about limiting renewable energy than protecting the environment.

    • Boyle Street Community Services and the Bissel Centre, Edmonton organizations that help people dealing with homelessness and poverty, partnered with the Northern Alberta Institute of Technology's culinary program to feed hundreds for the annual holiday at the downtown Boyle Street Plaza.

    • It was 11 months ago when Kris Knoblauch was brought in to coach the beleaguered Edmonton Oilers, who were near the bottom of the Western Conference standings with a 3-9-1 record.

    • Halifax police have charged a 41-year-old man in the death of his mother.

    • The Halifax Regional Municipality (HRM) is reminding residents that the second of two advance voting days for the 2024 Municipal and Conseil scolaire acadien provincial election will take place on Tuesday.

    • “Ken is a dreamerâ€: Saint John singer-songwriter Ken Tobias passes away at 79.

    • Sometimes love is written in the stars, but for one couple, it’s written in the aurora borealis.

    • Canadian stand-up comedian and former talk show host Mike Bullard has died.

    • A pack of dogs put their best paws forward when they were finally unleashed from a lifetime of animal testing.

    • Saskatchewan residents have just a few more days to catch a rare glimpse of a comet visible to the naked eye, streaking across the western skies at dusk.

    • With Saskatchewan's election set for Oct. 28, many voters may be wondering what candidates are running in their local ridings.

    • Saskatchewan Party Leader Scott Moe is accusing the union representing RCMP members of looking after its own interests.

    • Hundreds of people bundled up to take part in a longstanding Thanksgiving Day tradition in Kitchener.

    • According to police, when officers arrived they found the house fully engulfed in flames and were unable to make entry.

    • Police are looking for a missing 14-year-old boy from Kitchener.

    • Saskatchewan residents have just a few more days to catch a rare glimpse of a comet visible to the naked eye, streaking across the western skies at dusk.

    • With Saskatchewan's election set for Oct. 28, many voters may be wondering what candidates are running in their local ridings.

    • Just under one million ballots are being printed for the upcoming provincial election in Saskatchewan, and 27 out of the 61 constituencies currently have their ballots being pulled hot off the presses in Regina.

    • A Greater Sudbury woman is upset about the charges laid against the man accused of attacking her son and a group of his colleagues downtown on Saturday.

    • A 36-year-old man is charged with drug-impaired and dangerous driving after a head-on crash in northwest Ontario last Thursday.

    • One person has died and three others were transported to hospital following a three-vehicle collision in St. Clair Township

    • Smash Pickleball is the region’s only indoor facility dedicated specifically to the sport.

    • A Harriston man has been charged after police said the operator of an ATV crashed into a vehicle parked on Queen Street South in Harrison.

    • Provincial police remind motorists about the importance of buckling up after an officer discovered a passenger sitting on a kitchen chair inside the vehicle during a traffic stop in the Town of the Blue Mountains.

    • A recent study ranks Barrie last among large Canadian cities regarding homeowners who have paid off their mortgage.

    • Three teenagers are facing multiple charges for allegedly damaging property, a vehicle, a recreation centre and stealing a vehicle this weekend in Muskoka.

    • Chatham-Kent police say a 37-year-old Merlin man has died after a two-vehicle collision.

    • Windsor has the fifth highest rate of mortgage-free homeowners in Canada, according to a study by Casivoo.

    • The Town of Tecumseh is getting $1,789,764 from the Ontario government to help renew and rehabilitate critical infrastructure.

    • Just a couple of weeks after a new southern resident killer whale calf was first seen, its health appears to have taken a bad turn.

    • Vicki Huntington says two things are critical to be elected as an Independent member of the legislature in British Columbia — trusted name recognition and an angry constituency.

    • B.C.’s northern coast has been getting soaked by an atmospheric river over the Thanksgiving long weekend, with officials warning of heavy downpours and possible flooding.

    • Dave Lindsey began growing giant pumpkins to bring a bit of magic to his grandkids' Halloween.

    • A U.S. District Court judge in Montana has sentenced a 27-year-old man from Kelowna, B.C., to 18 months in prison for using fake names to buy guns with the aim of selling them in Canada.

    • Nearly two years after a man was stabbed to death in downtown Kelowna, RCMP have made an arrest in the case.

    • The Vancouver Giants scored late to force overtime before winning 4-3 over the Lethbridge Hurricanes Friday night.

    • If you’re looking for something to do this long weekend, the Lethbridge Corn Maze is open and hosting its annual fundraiser on Monday.

    • Local photographers were amazed by the aurora borealis display in the night sky over Lethbridge on Thursday night.

    • A 36-year-old man is charged with drug-impaired and dangerous driving after a head-on crash in northwest Ontario last Thursday.

    • Provincial police in Hearst, Ont., stopped an unlicensed northwestern Ontario driver for a morning traffic infraction.

    • A 32-year-old woman has been charged in connection with the death of an 18-year-old man this past January, according to Ontario Provincial Police.

    N.L.

    Stay Connected
    Follow Â鶹´«Ã½