How does it feel to see Bob Dylan win the Nobel Prize for Literature?
More than a few novelists were annoyed or downright angry that one of their peers was seemingly overlooked on Thursday, after the Nobel committee made Dylan the first-ever musician to win the award.
Scottish writer Irvine Welsh, who penned "Trainspotting," was among the most irate critics of the choice on Twitter. "I'm a Dylan fan," he , "but this is an ill-conceived nostalgia award wrenched from the rancid prostates of senile, gibbering hippies."
In another , Welsh attacked the choice for stretching the definition of literature to include a musician. "If you're a 'music' fan, look it up in the dictionary. Then 'literature'. Then compare and contrast."
Welsh also compared the decision to other examples that he said would be equally unjust. "Have they inducted Don De Lillo into the Rock n Roll hall of fame alongside Def Leppard and Slayer?" he wrote, in one . He also retweeted a tongue-in-cheek suggestion that celebrity chef Gordon Ramsay should win the prize for science.
I heard Gordon Ramsey has won the Nobel prize for chemistry, cos cooking and chemistry is the same innit?
— picklish (@picklishsleep)
And he wasn't on his own. Others also criticized the choice, with some pointing out that there are already plenty of other awards in existence to honour the efforts of musicians like Dylan.
Bob Dylan wins the Nobel Prize for Literature? What's next, Derek Jeter wins a Tony for his rice pilaf???
— rob delaney (@robdelaney)
Bob Dylan got the Nobel Prize in literature because everyone who listens to his music gets bored and decides to pick up a book instead
— Dollars Horton (@crushingbort)
I love me some Bob Dylan but I'm kinda bummed about him winning the Nobel Prize in Literature.
— Morgan Jerkins (@MorganJerkins)
The in literature goes to ! Wow. Maybe some women next year please? But this sure is awesome.
— Mayim Bialik (@missmayim)
Others came out in defence of Dylan, citing his poetic lyrics as all the evidence needed to show that he deserves the prize.
Folks: Songwriting is writing, and Bob Dylan is one of the most influential writers in the last 100 years. It's a defensible Nobel pick.
— John Scalzi (@scalzi)
Sorry, intellectual snobs, I'm with Bob.
— Max du Preez (@MaxduPreez)
I've read 18 other Nobel Prize Laureates. moved me as much as any of them.
— Patch Zircher (@PatrickZircher)
Congratulations and thanks.
Legends of music are not restricted to notes/ lyrics. They are carriers of faith& hope. Belief in the lyrical journey of life .
— Chaitanya Prasad (@Chatty111Prasad)
Woke up to he news that won the in literature. Few writers have seen their work have a greater influence. Let's party
— David Korins (@DavidKorins)
Congratulations to one of my favorite poets, Bob Dylan, on a well-deserved Nobel.
— President Obama (@POTUS)
I found out this minute that Bob Dylan, has won the Nobel Prize for literature!! Congratulations to you, Bob! What a great great day!
— Bette Midler (@BetteMidler)
Congratulations Bob for getting the Nobel prize. What an achievement !
— Mick Jagger (@MickJagger)
I'm not a huge Bob Dylan fan, but I appreciate his music and like the idea of challenging our ideas of what constitutes as *real* literature
— Clint Smith (@ClintSmithIII)
Amidst all the bullshit of this election came the news today that Bob Dylan won the Nobel Prize in Literature.Lifted my spirits!
— Michael Moore (@MMFlint)
Congratulations Bob Dylan! An inspired choice by the Nobel Committee for the Prize in Literature! My favorite writer;still "busy being born"
— Al Gore (@algore)
Congrats on a well-deserved Nobel for wise, powerful lyrics that touched minds & hearts. And TY for this amazing orig. sculpture!
— Bill Clinton (@billclinton)
Sara Danius, the permanent secretary of the Swedish Academy, explained the choice by comparing Dylan's lyrical poetry to the works of the ancient Greeks, which were often performed to music.
"Bob Dylan writes poetry for the ear," she said. "But it's perfectly fine to read his works as poetry."
With files from The Associated Press